company logo

Caol Ila

Brand
Scotland

Whiskies (6,781)

6,781 Caol Ila whiskies are currently listed on Whiskybase.

Whiskybase Rating

86.00

Average of all ratings

Whisky Reviews

88 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 54.6%
Stated Age 11
Id 288520
Floctomore scored this whisky 87 points Expert Junior

Extreme ash smoke. You're sucking on the burnt-out charcoal from last night's barbecue. And you're probably even sweeter doing it...

88.56 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 56.9%
Stated Age 10
Id 296364
Hvdree scored this whisky 85 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    84 84
  • Taste
    84 84
  • Finish
    87 87

92.2 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 44.9%
Stated Age 40
Id 132260
floatingchair scored this whisky 92 points Member Senior

Premium & intricately layered, standing toe-to-toe with the finest Caol Ila expressions. Its only shortcoming is that the proof could’ve been ramped up a notch.
  • Nose
    92 92
    92
  • Taste
    93 93
    93
  • Finish
    92 92
    92

89 / 100 rating
Size 700 ml
Strength 50.1%
Stated Age 19
Id 301047
Capodonich Plus scored this whisky 89 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    88 88
  • Taste
    89 89
  • Finish
    89 89

86.41 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 53%
Stated Age 14
Id 214282
Dramtastic.86 scored this whisky 87 points Expert Senior

  • Nose
    88 88
  • Taste
    86 86
  • Finish
    87 87

84.44 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 51.6%
Stated Age 12
Id 250642
paaliversen scored this whisky 87 points Expert Senior

Verry funny Caol Ila and incredible with this special peating they have completed on this.
  • Taste
    round peat

88.37 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 54.8%
Stated Age 16
Id 275985
rolabob scored this whisky 87 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    87 87
  • Taste
    88 88
  • Finish
    87 87

88.76 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 49.2%
Stated Age 26
Id 203717
binninin scored this whisky 89 points Member Senior

N - Ash, Smoky, Lemon, Simple Syrup, Madeleine, Milky, Iodine, Apple Mint, Herb, Nutmeg, Vanilla, Malty
P - Oily, Lemon, Smoky, Sea Spray, Simple Syrup, Salty, Fish, Green Grape, Hay, Spice, Green Tea, Seaweed, Grapefruit Peel
F - Hay, Aged Tea, Dry, Umami, Spice

83.61 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 43%
Stated Age 12
Id 23
malograna scored this whisky 85 points Expert Junior

91.42 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 50 ml
Strength 40%
Id 80456
peatbogger scored this whisky 90 points Specialist

Thanks to karloff for sharing what was left in this miniature.
It has held up amazingly.
Most reviews on this mention low fill level, a common thing with these old GM mininiatures.
Yet it has +91 points average on the 23 ratings.
Deserved. This is vintage magic.

Edit: After finishing it I dug out the refractometer and measured the ABV of the last drop. Most likely having been stored in indoor temperature this has had the tropical warehouse effect and had increased in ABV to 54%.
  • Nose
    89 89
    If you like old school whisky... I do, and this is it.
    Dunnage warehouse, old leather bound books.
    Not so much Islay peat, but it's coastal, maritime, with some smoke.
    What is the ABV left in this? Hard to say, It's not hard to notice it, but there's no spice.
    Some dry herbs, dark toast.
  • Taste
    91 91
    It arrives soft, but with a sense it still packs a punch.
    And it develops and delivers slowly.
    Nice wood, soft smoke, light peppery spice.
    Strawberries with chocolate. Thick caramel topping.
    It's very drinkable.
    Unusually lively in the way it keeps developing.
  • Finish
    90 90
    Herbal, a little mint, with dry smoke.
    A good mild cigar is a fitting comparison.

90.17 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 51.4%
Stated Age 35
Id 293175
Christzzz scored this whisky 88 points Expert Senior

  • Nose
    88 88
  • Taste
    88 88
  • Finish
    87 87

87.84 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 500 ml
Strength 55.7%
Stated Age 8
Id 221006
Damek scored this whisky 89 points Connoisseur

89,00
  • Nose
    89 89
    Nose: Exceptionally salty and sweet, salty and salted nuts, red and dark fruits, milk chocolate, chocolate-covered strawberry filling, sweet cherries, red and black currants, liqueur-coated raisins, cellar moisture, delicate salty smoke, a touch of pepper, salty leather. 88.50,
  • Taste
    89 89
    Palate: Much peatier and smokier than the aroma, maritime, exceptionally salty, very sweet, dark chocolate, burnt salty caramel, coffee, liqueur, a lot of cherry liqueur, wood stain, lots of tart wood, pleasant bitterness, slightly earthy, a bit dirty, red fruit, a hint of leather, after a while, a lot of coffee appears in the glass. 89.00
  • Finish
    88 88
    Finish: Medium-long, dark chocolate, coffee, cappuccino, nut syrup, leather, dust, pleasant dirt, a touch of moisture. After a while, dark fruit, multi-berry jam, and cinnamon emerge. 88.50

87.19 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 56%
Stated Age 12
Id 293571
Tuco1972 Plus scored this whisky 87 points Connoisseur

  • Nose
    87 87
  • Taste
    88 88
  • Finish
    86 86

86.5 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 54.8%
Stated Age 16
Id 275243
dramadram scored this whisky 86 points Expert Senior

  • Nose
    tropical fruits, honey, herbs, salty breeze, smoke
  • Taste
    more peat than on the nose, sweet, salty, rum, vanilla, honey
  • Finish
    sweet and earthy, goes on and on...

88.48 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 59.7%
Stated Age 9
Id 158860
Caracas scored this whisky 86 points Member Senior

Popper's brother to WB150352.
More balanced, less smoke, less spice, more fruit.

89.67 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 58.7%
Id 25612
ayoy Plus scored this whisky 89 points Expert Junior

  • Nose
    90 90
  • Taste
    89 89
  • Finish
    89 89

86.75 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 59.8%
Stated Age 10
Id 142654
92.3 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 63.8%
Stated Age 14
Id 25469
92.61 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 61.1%
Stated Age 17
Id 11335
92.39 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 700 ml
Strength 54.9%
Stated Age 40
Id 166076

Whiskybase logoWhiskybase

Build and track your whisky collection, rate and review bottles, check prices, and engage with like-minded enthusiasts. All things whisky since 2007.

Become a Supporter 

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

Whiskybase B.V.
Zwaanshals 530
3035 KS Rotterdam
The Netherlands 


KVK: 60207205
VAT: NL853809112B01