company logo

Penelope Bourbon

Bottler
Roselle, NJ, United States

Whiskies (84)

84 Penelope Bourbon whiskies are currently listed on Whiskybase.

Whiskybase Rating

81.00

Average of all ratings

Whisky Reviews

84.78 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 46.5%
Id 272784
Hanqing_Zhu scored this whisky 87 points Expert Senior

Had Rumba Reserve 50.9% version. Very sweet, but not as good as Rio
  • Nose
    87 87
  • Taste
    88 88
  • Finish
    86 86

84.5 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 57%
Stated Age 4
Id 258119
EnnongE did not rate this whisky Expert Senior

Nose: Soda, syrup, cherry, honey

Taste: Brown sugar

Finish: Soda, cherry

84 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 58%
Id 245231
smolar231 scored this whisky 80 points Expert Senior

  • Nose
    82 82
    noticeable alcohol, oak, rye, a bit of fruit, quite closed, brown sugar, vanilla
  • Taste
    78 78
    not very oily, spicy, lots of wood, little sweetness, astringent
  • Finish
    80 80
    medium-long, spicy, astringent

88 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 55%
Stated Age 5
Id 286076
Hanqing_Zhu scored this whisky 87 points Expert Senior

Had the 4 yo CAU Futures Batch
  • Nose
    87 87
  • Taste
    88 88
  • Finish
    87 87

84.5 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 57%
Stated Age 4
Id 258119
Sanma scored this whisky 84 points Expert Senior

  • Nose
    86 86
  • Taste
    84 84
  • Finish
    82 82

87.73 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 49%
Id 249040
Hanqing_Zhu scored this whisky 92 points Expert Senior

Had batch 25-901. Brilliant, never had something similar before. Honey cinnamon cake, very sweet. Might be my favourite bourbon, completely different style from traditional bourbon
  • Nose
    92 92
  • Taste
    93 93
  • Finish
    92 92

84.71 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 52%
Stated Age 4
Id 253628
90ClubWhisky scored this whisky 87 points Connoisseur

Dark amber color. Oily structure.
  • Nose
    87 87
    Sweetness. Caramel. Fattiness. Toffee. Honey. Orange peel. Vanilla bean. A hint of spice. A pinch of white pepper. Dark chocolate. Spices. Nutmeg. Cinnamon. Even clove. On the second nose, maple syrup arrives. Coconut.
  • Taste
    88 88
    Caramel. Honey. Toffee. Maple syrup. Leather. Tobacco. Oak. Spices. White pepper. Spices. Nutmeg. Cinnamon. Black coffee. Cocoa. Dark chocolate. Leather again. Tobacco leaves. Unlit cigar. Spices. Black pepper. Ginger. Oily structure.
  • Finish
    87 87
    Cocoa. Oak. Dark chocolate. Black, unsweetened coffee. Spices. Ginger. Black pepper. Cinnamon. Leather. Tobacco leaves. Unlit cigar. Very dry, but full-bodied and quite powerful with a marked spiciness. Quite a long finish.

86.75 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 50%
Stated Age 5
Id 253627
90ClubWhisky scored this whisky 85 points Connoisseur

Dark amber color. Oily structure.
  • Nose
    87 87
    Sweet aroma. Lots of caramel. Honey. Sweet wood. Sweet cocoa. Dark chocolate. Sweetened coffee. Mocha. Vanilla. Vanilla pudding. Maple syrup. Coconut. Bounty bar. Perfumed aromas. A touch of flowers. Spices. Nutmeg. Clove. Even more coconut on the second nose.
  • Taste
    83 83
    Toffee. Oak. Sweet wood. Traces of varnish. A touch of metallic. Oak emerges, bitterness. Heavily toasted barrel. Cocoa. Spices. Ginger. Black pepper. A certain oiliness in the structure. White pepper. Even cardboard aromas.
  • Finish
    84 84
    Caramel. Toffee. Dark chocolate. Lots of spice. Black pepper. Ginger. Chili. Oak. Heavily toasted barrel. Cocoa. Walnut. Very dry at the end. Medium-long finish.

84.78 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 46.5%
Id 272784
90ClubWhisky scored this whisky 86 points Connoisseur

Dark amber color. Oily structure.
  • Nose
    86 86
    Sweet and dry. Waxy. Overripe tropical fruit. Maple syrup. Molasses. More sweetness with time. Fatty toffee. Fudge. Caramel. Now drier again. A hint of tobacco. Dark chocolate. Cocoa. A hint of spice. A touch of spiciness. Maple syrup again. Honey. Caramel. Vanilla. More sweetness on the second nose. More honey. Pineapple drenched in maple syrup. A hint of coconut emerges.
  • Taste
    86 86
    Caramel. Toffee. Fudge. Overripe tropical fruits in syrup. Maple syrup. Oak. Cocoa. Dark chocolate. Tobacco. Honey. Maple syrup again. Heavily charred barrel. Spices. Spiciness. Freshly ground black pepper. Quite an oily texture.
  • Finish
    85 85
    Maple syrup. Honey. Apricots in syrup. Candied apricots. Toffee. Spices. Ginger. Black pepper. Medium-long finish.

87.73 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 49%
Id 249040
90ClubWhisky scored this whisky 86 points Connoisseur

Amber color. Oily structure.
  • Nose
    87 87
    Quite full-bodied and volatile. Sweet and light at the same time. Pleasant. Lots of vanilla. Vanilla in all its varieties. Both vanilla pudding and vanilla bean. Vanilla oil. Honey. A meadow with flowers just blooming. The nose even seems a little perfumed, but in a good way. After a while, a little heavier, but still sweet aromas. Caramel, toffee, fudge. Scottish tablet. After a while, maybe even a hint of fruit aromas. Caramelized pears. Lots of honey. It's not super complex, but very pleasant. On the third nose, plenty of cinnamon appears. Christmas gingerbread.
  • Taste
    86 86
    Very sweet. Honey. Loads of vanilla. Vanilla pudding. Sweet cake. Lots of honey. Spices. A touch of ginger. Cupcakes with icing. Maybe even a little too sweet. Quite an oily texture. Less sweetness on the second sip. Oak appears. Nutty notes. Walnut. Then the sweetness returns. Maple syrup. Still plenty of honey. On the next sip, cinnamon and Christmas gingerbread arrive.
  • Finish
    85 85
    Honey. Maple syrup. Oak. Deeply charred barrel. Spices. A bit of spice towards the end. Ginger. Hot peppers. Even a hint of chili. Medium-length finish.

82.43 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 40%
Id 187793
90ClubWhisky scored this whisky 79 points Connoisseur

Golden color. Quite oily texture.
  • Nose
    81 81
    At first, a hint of alcohol comes through. Nail polish. Caramel. Sweetness. Toffee. Fudge. Coconut. A hint of banana. Fresh wood. Spices. Black pepper. Vanilla. Vanilla pudding. It improves on the second nose. Definitely sweeter and lighter. Notes of caramel and vanilla dominate. Vanilla pudding. Vanilla oil. The alcohol is no longer detectable on the second try. On the third nose, sweet citrus emerges. Tangerines.
  • Taste
    79 79
    Quite dry at first. Fresh wood. Then a bit of sweetness. Caramel. Toffee. Fudge. Dry again. Burnt caramel. Oak barrel. Spices. Black pepper. Vanilla. Vanilla pudding. A hint of coconut. Sweet cream. The structure isn't oily. The second sip is weaker. Too much bitterness. A slight spiciness is still present.
  • Finish
    78 78
    Dry at the start. Oak. Cocoa. Spices. Black pepper. Strongly charred barrel. A touch of cream, but no longer sweet. Quite a bit of bitterness emerges. Slightly less dry after the second sip. Still plenty of spice. Ginger emerges. Medium-length finish.

84.71 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 52%
Stated Age 4
Id 253628
mrecho7 scored this whisky 87 points Expert Senior

  • Nose
    86 86
  • Taste
    87 87
  • Finish
    87 87

86.75 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 50%
Stated Age 5
Id 253627
mrecho7 scored this whisky 88 points Expert Senior

  • Nose
    87 87
  • Taste
    88 88
  • Finish
    88 88

82.43 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 40%
Id 187793
mrecho7 scored this whisky 84 points Expert Senior

87.73 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 49%
Id 249040
mrecho7 scored this whisky 87 points Expert Senior

  • Nose
    87 87
  • Taste
    88 88
  • Finish
    87 87

84.78 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 46.5%
Id 272784
mrecho7 scored this whisky 86 points Expert Senior

  • Nose
    86 86
  • Taste
    86 86
  • Finish
    85 85

86.75 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 50%
Stated Age 5
Id 253627
hugs_for_drugs scored this whisky 89 points Expert Junior

  • Nose
    89 89
    The nose on this Toasted is fantastic, one of my favorites in Bourbon, it completely covers the fact that this is only 5 years old. Carmel bomb.
    ah, that aroma, Penelope is charred #5, and since level 4 is described as 55 seconds, level 5 means that the charring took more than 55 seconds, but exactly how long is unknown.
    You can smell this bourbon and revel in it. Wood, caramel, sweet charcoal, toffee. It's sweet and gets even sweeter.
  • Taste
    88 88
    Since it's proof 100, it doesn't sting the tongue, spreads nicely to the sides, you can taste vanilla, toffee, oak (sweet again), a hint of pepper, it's good, but luckily that's not the end of the journey because...
  • Finish
    90 90
    And this is where Toasted Penelope shines, because it is Toasted Heavy, which means that in addition to the barrels being charred for a very long time, it was also toasted. Someone went all out here. And so, while the distillate itself may not impress with its complexity, and you can tell that it is young, the process used makes the finish on this crazy bottle a lot of fun. Long-lasting pleasure.
    All the flavors hit twice as hard and linger for quite a while.

84.71 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 52%
Stated Age 4
Id 253628
smolar231 scored this whisky 83 points Expert Senior

  • Nose
    85 85
    mild, delicate, caramel, bubble gum, sweet, red fruit, slightly closed, vanilla, honey, a bit of rye
  • Taste
    83 83
    more wood, caramel, not very oily, warming, cocoa, a bit astringent
  • Finish
    82 82
    medium-long, warming, sweet

87.33 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 110%
Stated Age 5
Id 283185
Bosconius scored this whisky 84 points Expert Junior

20% fill level opened for a few months. Neat out of a rocks glass. Cursory review. Better than expected based on the hype but not something I’d buy for myself. No noteworthy change with water.
  • Nose
    83 83
    Peanuts. Vanilla cream befitting of the name. Signature rye notes (cinnamon). Overall tight on the nose and straightforward. Honey.
  • Taste
    84 84
    Things improve here. Medium sweetness and spice. Not an overly woody profile and well balanced. Drinks easy for the ABV.
  • Finish
    85 85
    Medium+ length finish. Things stay in balance. The vanilla creaminess headlines the finish against a light backbone of brown baking spices.

87.33 / 100 rating
whisky photo
Size 750 ml
Strength 110%
Stated Age 5
Id 283185
gman4405 scored this whisky 90 points Expert Senior

I've waited 4 weeks and @ 80% bottle level to leave this review. It still amazes me how some whiskies open up to a much better flavor profile. This whiskey is delicious and a "Must Buy" if you can find it

Whiskybase logoWhiskybase

Build and track your whisky collection, rate and review bottles, check prices, and engage with like-minded enthusiasts. All things whisky since 2007.

Become a Supporter 

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

Whiskybase B.V.
Zwaanshals 530
3035 KS Rotterdam
The Netherlands 


KVK: 60207205
VAT: NL853809112B01