Overall rating
90.00/100
ratings
9
Whiskybase ID
WB51241
Category
Single Malt
Distillery
Bottler
Signatory Vintage (SV)
Bottling series
Vintage Collection - Miniature
Vintage
27.12.1974
Bottled
05.1995
Stated Age
20 years
Cask Type
Oak Cask
Cask number
12584
Number of bottles
850
Strength
55.7 %
Size
50 ml
Bottle code
95/1155
Added on
23 jan 2014 9:51 am by Hubertchen
UncoloredCask StrengthSingle Cask Whisky
Photo by Hubertchen
Overall rating
90.00/100
ratings
9

  Create a free account to see all known prices

Whisky reviews for Caol Ila 1974 SV

3 users have left 3 reviews for this whisky. Average rating is 90.00 points.

Read the reviews
  1. Thermidor scored this whisky 90 points Connoisseur

    A lovely old Caol Ila that's less coal-y than the more common 1980s ones, but obviously of the same DNA.
    • Nose
      Ahh, it's almost naked, with this plain, dry oak and worn cask vanilla. A faint fishy smell, followed by gentle, dry tar and seasoned salt. With water, the saltiness recedes and gives way to more vanilla, and parchments.
    • Taste
      This gentle tar is lovely, and so is the salty, dry oakiness, both backed by an intense peat that's slightly on the harsh, raking side, but not too much. This is just about as much pure distillate as you can get, and I do love it, but it ought to be just a little more expressive or powerful to get over 90 points from me. I don't quite understand the low WF score, though. Maybe it was a case of tired taste buds, since it was the last whisky reviewed that day?
    • Finish
      Gently tarry, salty, and a bit metallic. Water dispels the salt, giving way to more tar. I love this lingering dry oak that isn't acrid or astringent. Could be a little louder, though.

  2. Create a free Whiskybase account to read all 3 reviews for this whisky
    Create free account

Tasting tags lock-03

No tasting tags have been added yet. or create a free account to explore the full profile and add your own notes.

  • Chocolate
    Chocolate
  • Citric
    Citric
  • Coal-gas
    Coal-gas
  • Cooked Fruit
    Cooked Fruit
  • Cooked Mash
    Cooked Mash
  • Cooked Vegetable
    Cooked Vegetable
  • Dried Fruit
    Dried Fruit
  • Fragant
    Fragant
  • Fresh Fruit
    Fresh Fruit
  • Green-House
    Green-House
  • Hay-like
    Hay-like
  • Honey
    Honey
  • Husky
    Husky
  • Kippery
    Kippery
  • Leafy
    Leafy
  • Leathery
    Leathery
  • Malt Extract
    Malt Extract
  • Medicinal
    Medicinal
  • Mossy
    Mossy
  • New Wood
    New Wood
  • Nutty
    Nutty
  • Oily
    Oily
  • Old Wood
    Old Wood
  • Plastic
    Plastic
  • Rubbery
    Rubbery
  • Sandy
    Sandy
  • Sherried
    Sherried
  • Smokey
    Smokey
  • Solvent
    Solvent
  • Sweaty
    Sweaty
  • Toasted
    Toasted
  • Tobacco
    Tobacco
  • Vanilla
    Vanilla
  • Vegetative
    Vegetative
  • Yeasty
    Yeasty