WithKeys plus

Expert Senior  Senior Expert

About WithKeys:

I like beer.


About my reviews: Before I left Reddit for reasons well-known from the news, I spent several years posting my whisky reviews there, most of them naturally based on my own experiences. While my first favourite whiskies around 2012 were young, affordable, and bottled at 40% ABV, my palate has evolved a bit since then. Today, I'm almost embarrassed that the 16-year-old Bushmills got a top rating from me back in the day. I have long since transferred my reviews from Reddit over here, but I ask that you consider my scoring in the context of the time.

My favourite distilleries change from time to time, but you can spot them by how often they appear in my list of reviews. Nevertheless, I try to score in such a way that I don't give a bonus or a penalty to distilleries I think I already have an opinion on. No whisky has ever achieved a total score of 100 points from me, and only a few make it below 80. When it comes to the breakdown of nose, palate, and finish, the finish is almost irrelevant to my scoring, even though the Whiskybase rating system seems to have different priorities. So far, only the BenRiach 1994 (WB85893) and the Ardmore 1996 (WB102030) have managed a 100-point score for the nose; the palate and finish are still in the running.

You also have to see my scoring in relative terms: I find whiskies that get less than 84 points from me to be largely uninteresting, and anything below 70 points is unpleasant to drink. I'm more sensitive to sulphur than other reviewers, which makes some cask maturations harder to bear than others. I do, however, always review dreadful whiskies with a certain degree of goodwill. I never rule out the possibility of finding something even worse. The journey is what makes this hobby interesting to me.

  • Gender
    M
  • Germany
    de
  • Points
    2900
  • Check-in
    31

WithKeys Activity

Latest news

Check-in

Check-in’s not visible

Whiskybase logoWhiskybase

Build and track your whisky collection, rate and review bottles, check prices, and engage with like-minded enthusiasts. All things whisky since 2007.

Become a Supporter 

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

Whiskybase B.V.
Zwaanshals 530
3035 KS Rotterdam
The Netherlands 


KVK: 60207205
VAT: NL853809112B01