Overall rating
88.24/100
ratings
108
Whiskybase ID
WB228465
Category
Single Malt
Distillery
Bottler
Signatory Vintage (SV)
Bottling series
Horsemen & Archangels
Vintage
2012
Bottled
2022
Stated Age
10 years
Cask Type
Sherry Butt + Bourbon Hogshead
Number of bottles
1238
Strength
58.4 %
Size
700 ml
Label
Horseman No.1
Bottled for
Kirsch Import
Added on
16 mar 2023 1:55 pm by craide
UncoloredNon-chill FilteredCask Strength
Overall rating
88.24/100
ratings
108

  Create a free account to see all known prices

Whisky reviews for Caol Ila 2012 SV

20 users have left 20 reviews for this whisky. Average rating is 88.24 points.

Read the reviews
  1. Maltimex scored this whisky 90 points Expert Senior

    After the package with the Archangel and the Horseman had arrived, not only the former but also the Caol Ila had to be tasted directly. Yes, the price hurts, but if the Horseman is as convincing as the Archangel, then the purchase was worth it... So this is also the first tasting after the malt was allowed to breathe for about 30 minutes - I tasted it him to Ben Nevis.
    • Nose
      90 90
      Yes, there's a mighty campfire blazing on the cool Atlantic beach in the evening. Slightly fresh notes, most likely citrus fruits, rise, which for me in combination with the campfire smoke are characteristic of Caol Ila. The distillery character is therefore directly present, which speaks for the malt.
      The high alcohol content never bothers the nose and carries the clear but not obtrusive sherry aromas wonderfully to the nose, where they remind me most of sour cherries and forest honey. Now there are also impressions of coal.
    • Taste
      91 91
      This bottling is also convincing on the tongue: Here, too, a typical Caol Ila slides into the mouth and fills it with its campfire smoke and sour cherries. The counterpoint is set by the harmonious tannins and the citrus impressions. Everything is carried by the voluminous body. An association with walnuts comes to mind. The whisky is incredibly spoke-stimulating.
    • Finish
      90 90
      The finish is also here - similar to the Archangel - intense and long lingering. Sour impressions and campfire smoke - also coal - persist. This is where the oak flavors are most likely to develop into a full-bodied 70% chocolate.
      The pure Sherry Butt would probably have been too heavy and might not have left much of a Caol Ila either, so that the Bourbon Hogshead probably has a very positive effect on this great bottling. Well done, definitely.

  2. Create a free Whiskybase account to read all 20 reviews for this whisky
    Create free account

Tasting tags lock-03

18 tasting tags have been added by the community. or create a free account to explore the full profile and add your own notes.

  • Smokey
    Smokey
  • Tobacco
    Tobacco
  • Cooked Fruit
    Cooked Fruit
  • Dried Fruit
    Dried Fruit
  • Medicinal
    Medicinal
  • New Wood
    New Wood
  • Sherried
    Sherried
  • Chocolate
    Chocolate
  • Rubbery
    Rubbery
  • Oily
    Oily
  • Citric
    Citric
  • Coal-gas
    Coal-gas
  • Cooked Mash
    Cooked Mash
  • Cooked Vegetable
    Cooked Vegetable
  • Fragant
    Fragant
  • Fresh Fruit
    Fresh Fruit
  • Green-House
    Green-House
  • Hay-like
    Hay-like
  • Honey
    Honey
  • Husky
    Husky
  • Kippery
    Kippery
  • Leafy
    Leafy
  • Leathery
    Leathery
  • Malt Extract
    Malt Extract
  • Mossy
    Mossy
  • Nutty
    Nutty
  • Old Wood
    Old Wood
  • Plastic
    Plastic
  • Sandy
    Sandy
  • Solvent
    Solvent
  • Sweaty
    Sweaty
  • Toasted
    Toasted
  • Vanilla
    Vanilla
  • Vegetative
    Vegetative
  • Yeasty
    Yeasty