jonre723

Expert Junior  Junior Expert

About jonre723:

I use Serge Valentin's rating score:

100: free spot for hope.

95-99: absolutely stunning, a legend.

93-94: absolutely stunning, but there might be even better versions somewhere.

91-92: stunning, complex, balanced, with something extra (the wow factor!)

90: perfect, complex, balanced, but little ‘wow!’

88-89: almost perfect but maybe not totally complex and/or balanced.

86-87: maybe not totally perfect but very good and a good example of the make/brand. Not the tiniest flaw. Mature.

85: very good and very satisfying, but there are quite a few even better ones around in the same category. Mature. Maybe very minor flaws.

82-84: very good but can be a tad immature or unbalanced. Or a little uninteresting. Or have minor flaws.

80-81: good stuff no doubt, pleasant but maybe forgettable.

78-79: still good, loyal stuff but rather uninteresting.

75-77: drinkable, rather honest but has some moderate flaws. Blandness is a flaw.

70-74: drinkable but bland, simple, uninteresting. Can also have one or two obvious flaws.

60-69: there are quite a few obvious flaws but it’s still kind of drinkable.

50-59: at least one very major flaw (burnt notes, chemicals, stale…) but some other aspects can still be bearable. Sometimes of historical interest ;-).

25-49: obviously very flawed, and the flaws make it hard to swallow.

1-24: one shouldn’t be allowed to sell this. Many flaws, repulsive.

0: free spot for despair.

  • Gender
    M
  • Sweden
    se
  • Points
    1366
  • Check-in
    51

jonre723 Activity

Latest news

Check-in

Whiskybase logoWhiskybase

Build and track your whisky collection, rate and review bottles, check prices, and engage with like-minded enthusiasts. All things whisky since 2007.

Become a Supporter 

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play

Whiskybase B.V.
Zwaanshals 530
3035 KS Rotterdam
The Netherlands 


KVK: 60207205
VAT: NL853809112B01