10 × in wishlist
33 × member ratings
56 × in collection
Whisky Reviews for Ledaig 2005 TWM
9 users have left a review for this whisky and scored it an average of 87.10 points
- Serge Valentin of whiskyfun.com on 2016-05-31:
Ledaig 8 yo 2005/2014 (51.3%, The Whisky Mercenary) You know, since Diageo’s marvellous trick with their Lagavulin 8 yo, eight’s almost become the new twenty! Colour: white wine. Nose: it’s perhaps a little less ‘immediate’, and that may be because of the higher strength (yeah, only 3.2%, S.!) Other than that, styles, profiles, ideas, philosophies and goals in life are totally similar (S., there’s a lost episode of Inspektor Derrick on TV, you might want to go watch it.) With water: oh, we managed to reproduce the Malt Barn/Pure Spirit! A stroke of luck, perhaps. Mouth (neat): perfect. Lemon, peat, brine. I repeat, lemon, peat, brine. With water: same as the previous ones. Most probably not the same cask(s), but surely the same parcel. Finish: indeed. Comments: there's a question I got to ask you, isn’t Ledaig (slowly) becoming the new Ardbeg? SGP:357 – 89 points.
- Most of the Whisky Mercenary's picks are safe blind buys. So is this one. If you know what to expect of young Ledaig, this will not disappoint you. It ticks all the right boxes of an Islay alternative. Look hard and you still might find a bottle of it.
An aroma of vegetal peat immediately fill the room. Forget Airwick or those fancy perfumes. Just poor a dram of this Ledaig. Brine, seaweed and a wet beach. Fruit porridge for adults with vanilla and a shot of rakija. Blue grapes and stewed pears. Sweet paint. What a lovely nose!
Mixed with water you're treated to some wood stain and old pipe tobacco. It gets a bit sweeter over time. Ginger and oranges. Dried apricots and meat sauce. Pink marshmallow and a subtle hint of chlorine.
A creamy and greasy mouthfeel. Creosote, ash and smoke. A mix of roasted nuts. Very few sweet notes on the palate. Peper and first aid box. Dried black tea.
With water we're back with the sweetness. Pink marshmallows straight from the bonfire. A slightly bitter note of walnuts and coffee grounds. Dark cacao. A chocolate fondue next to a blazing fire.
The nutty character remains. A long medicinal and warm aftertaste. A shot of espresso.
Fig, orange, peat, peach, sweet dough and cow stables. The latter are pretty clean with plenty of straw. With water more citrus.
Peat, dark chocolate, gingerbread, orange, lime and fig. With a few drops of water the orange gets stronger.
Peat, toffee, orange, lime and dark chocolate. In the end a bit of candy like hard marshmallow.
- nose: Peat. Some fresh herbs, coriander, menthe. The peat is prevailing.
Initial taste: Peat. liquorish,
Body: medium-heavy. oily which is a pro
Finish: well even neat this is quite well, peaty afterburner.
Price: well if you like peated ones this is quite reasonable
presentation: I don't know this was a sample
comments: Sample from sampleswap with Hvdree
I don't seem to get to like peated whisky's forgive me for scoring this low!
- Great and assertive
Ledaig, that fulfilled my expectations fully. Around 70 EUR.
Ha! The nose is bull’s eye! Lots of assertive peat with a hint of a fish
barbecue. That is immediately followed by a lot of fruit. Think white fruit
(apples & pears), but also citrus. Mostly, though, something that reminds
me of melon. Wet rocks left, walnuts right. Drop of olive oil.
Soft pepper. A great start.
Nice and creamy
mouthfeel. Now it is the fruit that stands out, while the peat is
pressed into the shadows somewhat. But this is certainly very nice. Spicy with
ginger, pepper and even some liquorice. Midpalate, a salty edge appears.
The finish is
wonderfully long and smoky. The peat takes charge again.