Malthead19 scored this whisky 82 points

- much better than the original Peaty
- you can drink pure despite the high %, but with
Water more pleasant and better for me to drink
- for about 35€ top price, for currently around 100€ more
fewer
-
Campfire, coal, slightly sweet smell of smoke, lemon
-
without water: intensive, strong smoky attack, very warming, slowly drags down the throat, sweetness lingers, but smoke and alcoholic spiciness clearly dominate;
with W.: much more pleasant, the combination of sweetness and smoke comes out much better, toffee, vanilla, without the somewhat annoying sharpness caused by the high percentages -
long warmer smoky departure;
medium to long smoky reverberation