Don Cassi scored this whisky 73 points 
The nose starts out sweet and fruity with pears, unfortunately also a bit alcoholic. There is a slight note of dust over everything. With the addition of water, a little vanilla fights its way into the foreground and it becomes a little sweeter. Overall, however, much weaker than previous SU bottlings.
The alcohol tingles intensely in the mouth, and sweet and spicy notes and light grapes and banana spread out.
The finish is overlaid with a violent oak bitterness that kills the light fruit notes in the background.
Length: 4/10
Overall, one of the weaker SU bottlings: too young and yet too much oak flavor for the fragile, fruity distillery character. Probably a Balblair.
Grade: 2-
The alcohol tingles intensely in the mouth, and sweet and spicy notes and light grapes and banana spread out.
The finish is overlaid with a violent oak bitterness that kills the light fruit notes in the background.
Length: 4/10
Overall, one of the weaker SU bottlings: too young and yet too much oak flavor for the fragile, fruity distillery character. Probably a Balblair.
Grade: 2-
