Kantenmechaniker scored this whisky 84 points 
This is really bad to rate, because almost pure sherry, just with more alcohol, the smoke does not play a significant role here, it could really come from any distillery and would taste just the same. I was hoping for another Broadbay and am therefore a bit disappointed
-
A lot of sherry, almost a bit of glue, chocolate, raisins, almonds, behind all the sherry you can guess a bit of smoke, I wouldn't even see it as sweet, rather sour, very extreme, rarely smelled such a barrel-overloaded whisky
-
Sherry, of course, creamy, very sweet, PX, nut, roasted aromas, raisins, a little smoke now, too, very light ash, but the smoke dominates here too, it doesn't taste bad in the mouth, but it's also completely overloaded here, you can do it drink quite well
-
Sticky, raisins, sweet, light smoke, very pleasant, but not for too long
