No need to rate it 67 and 68 when you know how the rating system works on whiskybase.
68 is below a Johnnie walker red label when compared on this site, these "super administrators" can hardly be taken seriously.
Also curious, where did you taste it? Or did you hear about this malt from someone else? Take a look around at other Ledaigs from that period, they all seem to be less smoky than the current ones. I Strongly doubt this is written with any reference.
When 2 "super administrators" come up with the same score, we can all question their so called unbiased opinion. Comparing the taste with a garbage bag doesn't seem to be objective at all.