- Single Malt
- Gordon & MacPhail (GM)
- Bottling serie
- Connoisseurs Choice - Wood Finished
- Stated Age
- 14 years old
- Hermitage Wood Finish
- Batch 19/013
- Number of bottles
- 45.0 % Vol.
- 700 ml
- Added on
- 18 Apr 2019 5:41 pm by CortheFarmer
10 × in wishlist
51 × member ratings
93 × in collection
Whisky Reviews for Caol Ila 2005 GM
14 users have left a review for this whisky and scored it an average of 85.98 points
Red berries, strawberries, burnt wood, peat, winey, hints of spices and chocolate.
Burnt wood, peat smoke, wine-like flavor, hazelnut, mix of forest fruits, chocolate, nutmeg,
Medium, dry, burnt wood, peat smoke, mix of forest fruits, chocolate, nutmeg, hazelnut, wine-like flavor.
The Connoisseurs Choice from Gordon & Macphail has some new livery since a couple of months. Today I will try a 14 years old bottled at 45%, finished on Hermitage Wood for a year. Hermitage is a wine from the Northern Rhone region.
Oh, this is something else! The typical maritime character from Coal Ila is nicely wrapped in very sweet and fresh notes of red fruit. That must be the wine cask. Strawberries, raspberries and red berries with a hint of juicy plums and even some creamy banana. The salt and peat are pushed all the way in the back, though, but that’s quite alright. This is simply very good. After some fifteen minutes, it becomes quite candy-like. Dracula’s teeth, if you are familiar with that candy?
The malt is nicely oily and very quaffable. After the initial sweet bomb, mostly strawberry now – the saltiness finally emerges. Some pepper and peat kick in. I’m not sure I would have guessed this is Caol Ila if tasted blind, but I certainly know – blind or not – that I like it very much. Very successful wine finish, if you ask me.
It goes up and down like a yoyo in the finish: sweet tot salt to sweet to salt and so on.
Very atypical, but very good. Oh, well, is there any other Caol Ila?
- Balance (22)
Good wine, wine is not spoiled. (88)
Red berries, banana cream, prunes, lube oil with salt, peat, iodine ... after standing a farm appeared (22)
Sweet, ashen, strawberry (22)
The finish is sweet, ashen, a little salt and pepper ... smoke and tobacco, iodine (22)
- 21 21 20 21 83
Easy summer wine dessert for a drink.