Thermidor scored this whisky 81 points

Tasted with Caledonian 35yo HL 14271 (79 pts.), Caledonian 41yo HL 11836 (84), Carsebridge 41yo 1976 CA 49,1% (86), Carsebridge 44yo HL 14189 (82), and Carsebridge 52yo 1964 Dramfool 5th (89).
-
Flour and white sugar. Very light, with some dry oak. Water makes it a bit acidic and brings a note of shaved wood, with a side of cardamom.
-
Simple, with dry oak and sugar. Syrupy pastries, and some faint candy notes. Doesn't develop much with water, in fact I'd say it's best neat.
-
Hollow, but gentle and sweet.