22 × in wishlist
83 × member ratings
327 × in collection
Whisky Reviews for Lagavulin 08-year-old
5 users have left a review for this whisky and scored it an average of 83.58 points
- This is almost a teardrop sample from Glenkinchie distillery. Real earthy stuff with citrus fruits notes mixed with some stewed vegetables. Quality as usual from Lag.
Light smoke, some medicine in the background, alcohol well integrated, citrus fruits, all very discreet but not good
Much better than the Nosing. Mild, light sweetness but also peppery, hardly any smoke
Medium finish with lots of smoke
spicy smoke, sulfur notes dominate
Nose: there’s a bit more youth in this version. Whereas the bicentenary version is fairly balanced, this one is slightly rougher, with more hints of peanut butter, popcorn and the scented (new-makeish) notes of candyfloss. Slightly more alcoholic punch as well. Smoked meat. Lemon and pickle brine. Tarry ropes, but less earthy and less balanced than it predecessor.
Mouth: more of a young, mezcal-y character again, it seems its profile has shifted a little towards the 12. White pepper, big peat – and quite some heat. Sweet vanilla toffee and smoky oak in a second wave. Even more distillate-driven? Sooty, ashy, coastal. Smoked kippers. Still a bit of this nutty side.
Finish: long, warmer now, on roasted nuts, hints of chocolate, warm ashes and black pepper.
Although the ABV is identical, this one seems more in-your-face than the limited edition, as well as coming across younger. There’s a small chance that it comes down to bottle airing (the limited edition has been open since 2016) but in any case the limited edition was clearly the better one for me.