- Blended Malt
- Murray McDavid (MM)
- Bottling serie
- The Vatting - Limited Release
- Summer 2017
- Stated Age
- 27 years old
- Sherry Butt Finish
- Batch 001
- Number of bottles
- 44.9 % Vol.
- 700 ml
- Added on
- 18 Aug 2018 3:32 pm
5 × in wishlist
28 × member ratings
33 × in collection
Whisky Reviews for Malts of Islay - Àlainn 1989 MM
5 users have left a review for this whisky and scored it an average of 87.62 points
- 22 20 20 20 82
interesting nose, but then everything is simple and very simple, where is the age indicated on the bottle? sad ...
- I adore this honestly, and I reckon I won't be tasting something so atypical for the next 100 drams. Just super super original, and I think I want a bottle now. I just can't give less than 90 to something that has me both "wtf ??" and "wow" at the very same time. Its palate reminded me of the nose (and what I wish the palate the palate would have been) of this Glenisla, totally in the same "wtf" cluster. https://www.whiskybase.com/whiskies/whisky/66915/glenisla-1977-sv
See jazzpianofingers' intro for the trivia on this peculiar bottling. Its profile is no less atypical. On the nose I mostly get a very nice industrial smoke that feels both very Bowmore and very Laphroaig indeed, with truckloads of black olives, some "good" rubber, salmiak, leather, dates dipped in molten asphalt ... and some discrete red fruit element. Very good so far.
WTF. The arrival is very very soft, a bit watery, but then there's an incredible development that just screams late-80's Bowmore .... BUT, in a very good way for me. Shooting floral arrows one after the other : smoked violet cordial, rose-scented loukoum, raspberry yoghurt, ... In response to jazzpianofingers' review, and knowing we all have a diffierent sensibility to this, I didn't find it soapy at all. I've got a feeling like we have some pre-conception that just any Bowmore from that era is gonna be soapy : I think that sometimes there might be a confusion between soapy (which this one isn't in my very humble view), and floral (which this one is, tremendously). Just my two cents.
Rose water, burnt plastic, loukoums. The same kind of UFO. Short, that said.
It’s always worth popping over to Murray McDavid to speak to Dean. He always has interesting things to impart. Today he introduces us to ‘The Vatting’. A Jim McEwan experiment consisting of 90% Bowmore and 10% Laphroaig, married in a sherry butt sometime between 1997-1999 and bottled years later. Given I was chatting some, my notes are scant.
N: Some egg white, liquid onion peat,…
T: Soapy hints,.. an odd-ball.
F: I’m not sold on this though there is a decent malt base here. Cereal black currant on the finish.
C: Is that soap or TCP? Either way, it’s a bit weird.
Provisionally scores a D[+]
I ended up trying this again the following day. So, take 2:
N: I get the sherry for sure, a touch of smoke, more soapy TCP, meaty plasticine and a strange note that flickers between socks & flowers.
T: Soapy initially, leading to toasted ashy barley.
F: Road tar and lots more ash. A ‘dark’ finish.
C: The Laphroaig [style] is dominant, despite making up only 10% of this blend. Not quite the dog’s proverbials this one.
Scores a C[+]