malt70 scored this whisky 85 points

Three of the BiM bottlings in direct comparison: https://fosm.de/tasting-3x-brothers-in-malt-mortlach-und-ledaig/
-
Smoke with ginger is my first thought. Salt and spices. I can understand the rosemary. With some time comes caramelized brown sugar.
-
Pleasant tingling with smoke and ginger. Maltiness and vanilla with spices.
-
Menthol and light oak. Spices.