Whiskybase

McNeill's Choice

Average Rating

85.69

69 votes

Highest rated whiskies with > 3 votes
Photo by Slàinte Mhath
Name Stated Age Strength Size Bottled Casknumber Rating Versions Shoplinks
Deviant 1989 MNC Deviant 1989 MNC 25 42.7 % Vol. 700 ml 88.89
Erin's 2002 MNC Erin's 2002 MNC 12 56.5 % Vol. 700 ml 2015 84.00
Erin's II - 2002 MNC Erin's II - 2002 MNC 12 56.5 % Vol. 700 ml 2015 77.75
Green & White 12-year-old MNC Green & White 12-year-old MNC 12 60.0 % Vol. 500 ml 2016 85.00
McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC Experiment #002 05 59.7 % Vol. 700 ml 2015 86.25
McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC Experiment #008 05 57.9 % Vol. 700 ml 2016
McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC Experiment #013 05 57.6 % Vol. 700 ml 2017 87.00
McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC Experiment #007 05 56.9 % Vol. 700 ml 2015 88.00
McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC Experiment #010 05 58.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2016 85.22
McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC Experiment #005 05 56.8 % Vol. 700 ml 2015 86.00
McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC Experiment #015 05 56.7 % Vol. 700 ml 2018 85.75
McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC Experiment #004 05 56.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2015 90.00
McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC Experiment #014 05 57.9 % Vol. 700 ml 2017 84.00
McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC Experiment #001 05 55.4 % Vol. 700 ml 2015 85.00
McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC Experiment #011 05 57.9 % Vol. 700 ml 2016 87.50
McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC Experiment #003 05 57.7 % Vol. 700 ml 2015 86.00
McNeill's Prototype 05-year-old MNC Experiment #009 05 58.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2016 85.50
Peat Bog Fire 2009 Peat Bog Fire 2009 No. 2 10 55.6 % Vol. 700 ml 2020 87.25
Peat Bog Fire 2009 Peat Bog Fire 2009 No. 1 10 56.7 % Vol. 700 ml 2020 87.00
Peat Bog Fire 2010 Peat Bog Fire 2010 No. 1 - Second Edition 10 57.6 % Vol. 700 ml 88.25
Peat Bog Fire 2010 Peat Bog Fire 2010 No. 2 - Second Edition 10 56.3 % Vol. 700 ml 87.00
The OA Islay 05-year-old MNC Premium Line 05 57.7 % Vol. 700 ml 83.67
The OA Islay 05-year-old MNC Dumpy bottle 05 40.0 % Vol. 500 ml
The OA Islay 05-year-old MNC The OA Islay 05-year-old MNC Dumpy bottle 05 58.0 % Vol. 500 ml 82.00
The OA Islay 05-year-old MNC The OA Islay 05-year-old MNC Premium Line 05 58.0 % Vol. 700 ml 83.00
The OA Islay 05-year-old MNC YIM The OA Islay 05-year-old MNC YIM Premium Line 05 40.0 % Vol. 700 ml 82.00
The OA Islay YIM MNC Premium Line 40.0 % Vol. 700 ml
Vernal Awakening Young Islay Malt Vernal Awakening Young Islay Malt 59.0 % Vol. 700 ml 87.33
Aberlour
Aberlour 1993 MNC 16 56.2 % Vol. 500 ml 2009 84.00
Ardbeg
Ardbeg 1992 MNC Ardbeg 1992 MNC 10 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2002 426 84.00
Arran
Arran 1996 MNC Goat's Fell 17 54.0 % Vol. 700 ml 83.00
Arran 1996 MNC Arran 1996 MNC Firth of Clyde 18 54.1 % Vol. 700 ml 2015 90.00
Arran 1996 MNC Raonasa 18 49.3 % Vol. 700 ml 2015 86.50
Auchentoshan
Auchentoshan 1999 MNC 10 53.7 % Vol. 500 ml 2010 McNeill 002 82.00
Auchroisk
Auchroisk 1991 MNC Auchroisk 1991 MNC Remote 22 46.2 % Vol. 700 ml 2014
Aultmore
Aultmore 17-year-old MNC Aultmore 17-year-old MNC Premium Line 17 58.7 % Vol. 700 ml 80.50
Aultmore 1989 MNC Aultmore 1989 MNC Rare Vintage 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2003 2147
Aultmore 1990 MNC Attraction 22 52.9 % Vol. 700 ml 85.00
Aultmore 2011 MNC Aultmore 2011 MNC 08 66.0 % Vol. 700 ml 84.00
Aultmore 2011 MNC Aultmore 2011 MNC 08 66.7 % Vol. 700 ml 82.33
BenRiach
BenRiach 1990 MNC Ideal 24 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml
Benrinnes
Benrinnes 1988 MNC Speyside Special Reserve 15 55.9 % Vol. 700 ml 2003 886
Benrinnes 1998 MNC Benrinnes 1998 MNC 13 57.7 % Vol. 700 ml 86.67
Blair Athol
Blair Athol 15-year-old MNC Celtic Events 15 43.0 % Vol. 700 ml
Blair Athol 1989 MNC 61.2 % Vol. 700 ml 2000 4747
Blair Athol 25-year-old MNC Perth Road Natural Cask Strength 25 55.5 % Vol. 700 ml 79.00
Bowmore
Bowmore 1989 MNC Bowmore 1989 MNC 58.2 % Vol. 700 ml 2001 1976
Bowmore 1989 MNC Bowmore 1989 MNC 53.2 % Vol. 700 ml 2002
Bowmore 1990 MNC 53.2 % Vol. 700 ml 2002
Bowmore 1991 Octave MNC Bowmore 1991 Octave MNC Premium Line 13 61.6 % Vol. 700 ml 2005 1117 87.00
Bowmore 1992 MNC Bowmore 1992 MNC 10 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2002 76.00
Bowmore 1992 MNC Bowmore 1992 MNC Vintage 1992 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2003
Braeval
Braes of Glenlivet 1989 MNC Braes of Glenlivet 1989 MNC Buaidh No Bas 23 54.2 % Vol. 700 ml 84.50
Bruichladdich
Bruichladdich 1969 MNC Bruichladdich 1969 MNC 52.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2001 4838
Bruichladdich 1991 MNC Bruichladdich 1991 MNC 10 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2002 83.00
Bunnahabhain
Bunnahabhain 1990 MNC Bunnahabhain 1990 MNC Extravaganza 2nd Edition 21 54.5 % Vol. 700 ml 2011 89.00
Bunnahabhain 1990 MNC Bunnahabhain 1990 MNC 20 49.7 % Vol. 700 ml 2010 86.00
Bunnahabhain 1997 MNC 12 54.4 % Vol. 500 ml 2010 McNeill 003 87.50
Bunnahabhain 2001 MNC Bunnahabhain 2001 MNC Red Beggar 08 60.3 % Vol. 500 ml 2010 2959 83.08
Caol Ila
Caol Ila 15-year-old MNC Caol Ila 15-year-old MNC Premium Line 15 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml
Caol Ila 1991 MNC Caol Ila 1991 MNC Premium Line 14 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2005 356
Caol Ila 1999 MNC Traditional 06 40.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2005
Caol Ila 21-year-old MNC Caol Ila 21-year-old MNC McNeill's Premium Line 21 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml
Clynelish
Clynelish 09-year-old MNC Clynelish 09-year-old MNC Premium Line 09 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 84.00
Clynelish 1997 MNC Clynelish 1997 MNC Buaidh No Bas 14 53.7 % Vol. 700 ml 2011 89.50
Cooley
Cooley 1997 MNC 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2003
Dailuaine
Dailuaine 1992 MNC Dailuaine 1992 MNC 20 54.1 % Vol. 700 ml 86.67
Dalmore
Dalmore 2000 MNC Dalmore 2000 MNC 11 52.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2011
Glen Elgin
Glen Elgin 1991 MNC 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2003 4074
Glen Grant
Glen Grant 1988 MNC 54.3 % Vol. 700 ml 2004 50888
Glen Moray
Glen Moray 10-year-old MNC 10 40.0 % Vol. 700 ml 78.00
Glenlivet
Glenlivet 1990 MNC Glenlivet 1990 MNC Premium Line 16 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2006
Glenrothes
Glenrothes 1969 MNC Glenrothes 1969 MNC Rare Vintage 53.4 % Vol. 700 ml 2000 19217 93.03
Glenrothes 1969 MNC Glenrothes 1969 MNC 53.4 % Vol. 700 ml 2001 19217 91.27
Glenrothes 1985 MNC Premium Line 24 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2009 84.75
Glentauchers
Glentauchers 1996 MNC Glentauchers 1996 MNC PX 17 44.0 % Vol. 700 ml 88.50
Glentauchers 1996 MNC Glentauchers 1996 MNC Almost Black 17 47.4 % Vol. 700 ml 89.44
Highland Park
Highland Park 1992 MNC Highland Park 1992 MNC 10 40.0 % Vol. 700 ml 86.25
Imperial
Imperial 1998 MNC Imperial 1998 MNC 11 54.5 % Vol. 500 ml 2010 McNeill 004 88.00
Invergordon
Invergordon 1991 MNC Invergordon 1991 MNC 23 50.7 % Vol. 700 ml 2015 88.67
Longmorn
Longmorn 09-year-old MNC Premium Line 09 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml
Macallan
Macallan 13-year-old MNC Macallan 13-year-old MNC 13 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2002 85.00
Macallan 1988 MNC Macallan 1988 MNC 17 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2006
Macallan 1989 MNC Macallan 1989 MNC 13 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2002 89.00
Macallan 1997 MNC Premium Line 12 51.7 % Vol. 500 ml 2010 McNeill 005 85.00
Mortlach
Mortlach 12-year-old MNC Mortlach 12-year-old MNC Premium Line 12 40.0 % Vol. 700 ml 85.00
Mortlach 17-year-old Mortlach 17-year-old Outlander 17 59.5 % Vol. 500 ml 84.67
Mortlach 17-year-old MNC 17 52.2 % Vol. 700 ml 89.00
North British
North British 1991 MNC North British 1991 MNC 21 57.3 % Vol. 700 ml 89.50
North British 20-year-old MNC North British 20-year-old MNC 20 55.0 % Vol. 700 ml 89.50
Strathclyde
Strathclyde 1988 MNC Strathclyde 1988 MNC Moffat 27 54.8 % Vol. 700 ml 2015 84.50
Strathisla
Strathisla 2005 MNC Strathisla 2005 MNC Almost Black 08 55.5 % Vol. 700 ml 2013 89.00
Tomintoul
Tomintoul 16-year-old MNC 16 43.0 % Vol. 700 ml
Tomintoul 1967 MNC 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2003 85.50
Tormore
Tormore 15-year-old MNC Tormore 15-year-old MNC Celtic Events 15 46.0 % Vol. 700 ml 2005
Tullibardine
Tullibardine 2006 MNC Tullibardine 2006 MNC Almost Black 11 58.7 % Vol. 700 ml 2017 86.57

Whiskybase

Whiskybase is founded in 2007 with the goal to create the biggest resource of whisky information in the world. A community driven website built by and for whisky enthusiasts.  




Whiskybase B.V. 
Zwaanshals 530 
3035 KS Rotterdam 
The Netherlands 

KVK: 52072819
VAT: NL850288836B01

Copyright © 2021


Whiskies

Shop




Market



General

We use cookies to improve your online experience. By using this site, you consent to this use as described in our Privacy Policy.

Forgot your password?

Login